Bookmark and Share

Recent News

10/16/2014 - Explosion of a Low-Mass Helium Star in a Binary — First Evidence of a Hydrogen-deficient Supernova Progenitor

(Originally published by the University of Tokyo)

October 16, 2014

An artist’s conception of a binary progenitor system of the supernova iPTF13bvn. Larger diameter but smaller mass (4 times mass of the Sun) herium star shown on the left is to explode. The companion star shown on the right is a hydrogen rich star and 30 times mass of the Sun.timAn artist’s conception of a binary progenitor system of the supernova iPTF13bvn. Larger diameter but smaller mass (4 times mass of the Sun) helium star shown on the left is to explode. The companion star shown on the right is a hydrogen rich star and 30 times mass of the Sun.tim

A group of researchers led by Melina Bersten of Kavli IPMU recently presented a model that provides the first characterization of the progenitor for a hydrogen-deficient supernova. Their model predicts that a bright hot star, which is the binary companion to an exploding object, remains after the explosion. To verify their theory, the group secured observation time with the Hubble Space Telescope (HST) to search for such a remaining star. Their findings, which are reported in the October 2014 issue of The Astronomical Journal, have important implications for the evolution of massive stars.

For years astronomers have searched for the elusive progenitors of hydrogen-deficient stellar explosions without success. However, this changed in June 2013 with the appearance of supernova iPTF13bvn and the subsequent detection of an object at the same location in archival images obtained before the explosion using the HST. The interpretation of the observed object is controversial. The team led by Bersten presented a self-consistent picture using models of supernova brightness and progenitor evolution. In their picture, the more massive star in a binary system explodes after transferring mass to its companion.

One of the challenges in astrophysics is identifying which star produces which supernova. This is particularly problematic for supernovae without hydrogen, which are called Types Ib or Ic, because the progenitors have yet to be detected directly.

Supernova iPTF13bvn discovered in nearby spiral galaxy NGC 5806 (Image Credit: Jean Marie Llapasset)Supernova iPTF13bvn discovered in nearby spiral galaxy NGC 5806 (Image Credit: Jean Marie Llapasset)

However, the ultimate question is: “How do progenitor stars remove their hydrogen-rich envelopes during their evolution?” Two competing mechanisms have been proposed. One hypothesizes that a strong wind produced by a very massive star blows the outer hydrogen layers, while the other suggests that a gravitationally bound binary companion star removes the outer layers. The latter case does not require a very massive star. Because these two scenarios predict vastly different progenitor stars, direct detection of the progenitor for this type of supernova can provide definitive clues about the preferred evolutionary path.

When young Type Ib supernova iPTF13bvn was discovered in nearby spiral galaxy NGC 5806, astronomers hoped to find its progenitor. Inspecting the available HST images did indeed reveal an object, providing optimism that the first hydrogen-free supernova progenitor would at last be identified. Due to the object’s blue hue, it was initially suggested that the object was a very hot, very massive, evolved star with a compact structure, called a “Wolf-Rayet” star. (Using models of such stars, a group based in Geneva was able to reproduce the brightness and color of the pre-explosion object with a Wolf-Rayet star that was born with over 30 times the mass of the Sun and died with 11 times the solar mass.)

Right: Spiral galaxy NGC5806 Left top: Zoomed image of supernova iPTF13bvn just after the explosion. Left bottom: HST image taken before the explosion. Progenitor of iPTF13bvn was identified. (Image Credit: Iair Arcavi, Weizmann Institute of Science, PTF,Right: Spiral galaxy NGC5806 Left top: Zoomed image of supernova iPTF13bvn just after the explosion. Left bottom: HST image taken before the explosion. Progenitor of iPTF13bvn was identified. (Image Credit: Iair Arcavi, Weizmann Institute of Science, PTF)

"Based on such suggestions, we decided to check if such a massive star is consistent with the supernova brightness evolution," says Melina Bersten. However, the results are inconsistent with a Wolf-Rayet star; the exploding star must have been merely four times the mass of the Sun, which is much smaller than a Wolf-Rayet star. “If the mass was this low and the supernova lacked hydrogen, our immediate conclusion is that the progenitor was part of a binary system,” adds Bersten.

Because the problem requires a more elaborate solution, the team set out to simulate the evolution of a binary system with mass transfer in order to determine a configuration that can explain all the observational evidence (a blue pre-explosion object with a relatively low mass devoid of hydrogen). “We tested several configurations and came up with a family of possible solutions,” explains Omar Benvenuto of IALP, Argentina. “Interestingly, the mass transfer process dictates the observational properties of the exploding star, so it allows suitable solutions to be derived even if the mass of the stars is varied,” adds Benvenuto. The team chose the case where two stars are born with 20 and 19 times the mass of the Sun. The mass transfer process causes the larger star to retain only four times the solar mass before exploding. Most importantly, the smaller star may trap part of the transferred mass, becoming a very bright and hot star.

The existence of a hot star would provide strong evidence for the binary model presented by Bersten and collaborators. Fortunately, such a prediction can be directly tested once the supernova fades because the hot companion should become evident. “We have requested and obtained observation time with the HST to search for the companion star in 2015,” comments Gaston Folatelli of Kavli IPMU. “Until then, we must wait patiently to see if we can identify the progenitor of a hydrogen-free supernova for the first time,” Bersten adds.

Light curve of hydrodynamical modeling of iPTF13bvn (Solid red line: 4 solar mass, Solid blue line: 8 solar mass) and observations (dots). Brightness is shown in log of erg/s. Low mass model gives good representation of the observation. Light curve of hydrodynamical modeling of iPTF13bvn (Solid red line: 4 solar mass, Solid blue line: 8 solar mass) and observations (dots). Brightness is shown in log of erg/s. Low mass model gives good representation of the observation. 

 

iptf13bvnE04: Predicted spectrum of the binary progenitor system (solid lines) compared with HST measurement before explosion.iptf13bvnE04: Predicted spectrum of the binary progenitor system (solid lines) compared with HST measurement before explosion.

Return to News Listings